Vaccine rollout – it takes a village, part 2

Last week’s blog post on vaccine rollout took longer than expected to write as I compiled multiple resources and articles to comment on and share. With the vaccine rollout as massive an undertaking as it is and so many stories (good and bad), I decided to do part 2 this week highlighting best practices, technology challenges, and health disparities.

Best Practices

Last week, I mentioned Atrium Health and their local partnership to do mass vaccination events. It was encouraging to see their update on vaccinating over 20,000 people had a special emphasis on underserved communities.  We need more focus on underserved communities – more on that in a bit.

Another health system doing drive thru vaccination clinics at scale is Memorial Hermann in the Houston area. They are getting calls from health systems across the U.S. asking for guidance on how to design similar large-scale vaccination events and are more than willing to share their blueprint for others to replicate according to Binita Patel, Vice President of Pharmacy Services for Memorial Hermann Health System. The location (NRG Park) and staffing (700 people including many volunteers) were key to their success.

We cannot forget that there are many people leery of the vaccine, sometimes referred to as “vaccine hesitancy”. Education and public health messaging campaigns will be key as the vaccine rollout continues over the next several months. Based on the Kaiser Family Foundation’s latest COVID-19 Vaccine Monitor report, there are key messages that resonate with people. They are listed in this short article from Becker’s Health IT : “8 most convincing messages to promote COVID-19 vaccines”.

Many health IT vendors pivoted their products and services to support COVID-19 over the past year. Vaccine scheduling is the latest focus area for vendors like Kyruus which shared best practices and insights from their customers in their recent blog: “Eight Best Practices for COVID-19 Vaccine Scheduling Online: Insights From Our Health System Customers”. A great transition to the next topic.

Technology Challenges

I mentioned the Vaccine Access Management System (VAMS) in my post last week as a system provided by CDC to states and other organizations for pre-screening, registration, scheduling and tracking. Not surprisingly, a software solution developed quickly and made available for many different but similar situations and workflows has experienced problems as captured in this article from MIT Technology Review. I would hope the problems can be resolved so organizations using it do not have to switch systems midstream with vaccine rollout already in process and moving rapidly. Continue reading

Vaccine rollout – it takes a village

The vaccine is top of mind for many of us and a lead news story most days. Whether we are in a prioritized group wondering when/how/where we will be able to get the vaccine or are helping a family member in one of those groups sort it out. We are disappointed to hear the supply from Pfizer and Moderna is so limited at this stage. We are frustrated and anxious not knowing when we will be able to get the vaccine.

I share all those feelings. I am anxiously waiting to learn when my state of Rhode Island will start vaccinating 65+ so I can get my husband and I an appointment. With the percent of doses administered overall in Rhode Island only 56% of what has been distributed and our state currently receiving just 14,000 new doses each week, I am not optimistic that it will be soon.

In spite of any frustration you may feel about your own state’s progress, the good news at the macro level is that in the last week, an average of 1.25 million doses per day were administered in the U.S. That is even better than the goal of 1 million per day for the first 100 days of the Biden Administration. And there is more good news regarding the supply – 200 million more doses were ordered by the Biden Administration this week with the expectation that there will be enough doses for everyone who wants the vaccine by sometime this summer.

We know that vaccine plans vary by state. How to Get a COVID-19 Vaccine: A State-by-State Guide from the Wall Street Journal provides state website links and brief description of each state’s status. States vary on how groups are prioritized, the scheduling process and systems used, and the total number of doses available. In the 65+ group, I have friends and family who have driven more than 500 miles around their state for separate husband and wife appointments that they could only make at two different locations due to the demand, a couple who was only able to register for a lottery with 8000 doses to serve 250,000 people, a couple who relatively easily made appointments at their grocery chain to receive the vaccine from the pharmacist, and a couple who relatively easily made an appointment at a local community vaccine site.

The New York Times has a vaccine calculator – Find Your Place in the Vaccine Line – that puts it into perspective. You enter a few key data points and can see where you are in line within the U.S., your state, and your county – in other words how many thousands or millions of people are ahead of you. The graphic it produces helps you understand the order of groups and their relative size.

There are two trackers you might find interesting. The Johns Hopkins Coronavirus Resource Center tracks cases, testing and vaccines by state. You can see how your state is doing and where it ranks on vaccinations. The Bloomberg tracker shows how your state is doing by percent of doses used and number of doses administered.

There is a software system available from the CDC for states, counties and other organization to use – Vaccine Access Management System (VAMS). It handles pre-screening, registration, scheduling, and tracking. My state of Rhode Island will use PrepMod – a software solution in use by several states. Health systems appear to be using their own systems and assuming that patients can schedule through their patient portal or by phone. Some allow you to create an account if not already a patient.

I think we can all agree that front line health care workers needed to be first in line for the vaccine. But there have been stories of health systems vaccinating employees who only work from home, volunteers who aren’t coming into the hospital during the pandemic, board members and others who don’t appear to be in priority groups per the CDC guidelines. These systems have defended their actions by saying the more people vaccinated and the sooner is good for the community and that all staff are critical to the hospital’s operations. I can understand the frustration of people who are patients of those systems and in a prioritized group (such as elders or with underlying conditions) yet still waiting to learn when they will get the vaccine.

Let’s pivot to some positive stories of vaccine partnerships involving health systems to deliver shots in arms at scale. Continue reading

400,000 lives lost – finally a national strategy

On December 14 with the first frontline workers in the U.S. starting to receive the vaccine there was great optimism and hope that we had entered a new chapter of this pandemic. But six weeks later over 100,000 more people have died of COVID-19 and only 16.5M of the total 36M vaccine doses distributed have been administered. 5% of the U.S. population has been vaccinated though only 2.1M people have received the full two doses.

On Tuesday night, on inauguration eve, the new administration held a National Moment of Unity and Remembrance. A simple ceremony in front of the Lincoln Memorial to mourn and honor the over 400,000 people who have lost their lives to COVID-19 in less than a year. President Joe Biden and Vice President Kamala Harris spoke briefly, an ICU nurse from Michigan sang Amazing Grace, and 400 beams of light were lit up along the reflecting pool in front of the Washington Monument – one for every 1000 lives lost. Across the country bells tolled and buildings were lit up. It was a simple yet moving and much needed moment for all of us.

Five hours after President Biden took the oath of office on Wednesday, he was signing his first set of executive orders. Three of them including the very first were directly aimed at the pandemic – “100 days masking challenge”, rejoining the World Health Organization (WHO), and creating the position of COVID-19 response coordinator. Dr. Anthony Fauci is the U.S. representative to the WHO executive board and joined his first call on Thursday. Jeff Zients, who served as chief performance officer under President Barack Obama and led the rescue of HealthCare.gov, has begun his work as the COVID-19 response coordinator. Zients is “ready to manage the hell out of it”, as Biden said last Friday.

The new administration is getting right to work, and the pandemic is a top priority. A National Strategy for the COVID-19 Response and Pandemic Preparedness was released yesterday. Continue reading

8 health experts to follow

In past years, I’ve used the end of the year mark as a way to highlight my most read blogs of the year and encourage you to check them out if you missed them. But who cares about my most read blogs? Instead, I want to amplify the voices of health experts who have educated us throughout this pandemic and who will continue to for many months to come. If you aren’t already following them on social media or listening to their podcasts, I encourage you to do so. They are often interviewed on the major news programs.

Trusting the science, knowing the facts, and maintaining objectivity are critical for all of us to do our part and get safely to the other side of this pandemic.

Here are the experts I recommend you follow in alphabetical order:

Esther Choo, MD, MPH, Co-Founder, Equity Quotient, is an emergency physician and professor at the Oregon Health & Science University. She has been speaking from the front lines of the pandemic since the beginning. She did a podcast series called Doctors’s Log – A Covid-19 Journal in the early months of the pandemic. Twitter: @choo_ek

Laurie Garrett is a Pulitzer Prize winning science journalist and author of several books including “The Coming Plague: Newly Emerging Diseases in a World Out of Balance” and “Betrayal of Trust: The Collapse of Global Public Health”. In 2007, she did a TED talk “Lessons from the 1918 Flu”.  Twitter: @Laurie_Garrett

Ashish Jha, MD, MPH, is an internationally respected expert on pandemic response and preparedness. He recently left his position as faculty director of the Harvard Global Health Institute and became dean of the Brown University School of Public Health.  His recent interview on In the Bubble with Andy Slavitt, “The Next Three Stages of COVID-19”, is worth checking out. And as I just learned, he also has his own podcast series, “COVID: What Comes Next”. He is a frequent contributor on all the major news outlets. Twitter: @ashishkjha

Vivek Murthy, MD, MBA, has been nominated as the next U.S. Surgeon General, a role he also served in during the Obama Administration.  He is the co-chair of the Biden COVID Task Force. His recent interview on in the Bubble with Andy Slavitt, “Inside the Biden COVID Task Force”, is worth checking out. Twitter: @vivek_murthy

Michael Osterholm, MS, MPH, PhD, is the director of the Center for Infectious Disease Research and Policy (CIDRAP) at the University of Minnesota and is a world-renowned epidemiologist who has spent his career investigating outbreaks. He is a member of the Biden COVID Task Force. Continue reading

V-Day – With the vaccine comes hope

The UK administered the first fully tested and approved COVID-19 vaccine this week. The U.S. could be administering the vaccine as early as next week. There is hope!

Projections are that by summer 2021, most everyone in the U.S. who wants a vaccine will be able to get it. There is hope!

The Biden Administration’s health team has been announced. There will be a new reliance on clinicians, scientists, and public health experts. There is hope!

And yet, the challenges are many. To name just a few: overall supply vs demand, distribution logistics and storage, logistics of administering the vaccine, establishing guidelines for prioritized groups to receive it, ensuring both doses are administered at the right time interval, and of course public trust in the vaccine.

As I have read and listened the past week, I have learned how the free market impacts the availability of key components for the manufacturers, that each state can decide on their group priorities after the CDC publishes the guidelines, and that only about 60% of the population say they are willing to take the vaccine.

On a more encouraging note, I have heard how provider organizations have been developing their vaccine administration plan for months and how a leading pharmacy chain is planning to scale administration across their 10,000 locations and has an app ready to go for tracking patients, scheduling appointments, and sending reminders for the second dose.

I encourage you to check out these resources to understand the issues involved:

In the Bubble with Andy Slavitt podcast – Toolkit: Where and When Can I Get the Vaccine? He talks about the science with Dr. David Agus and the logistics with CVS Health’s Tom Moriarty. Together they answer questions from listeners.

Interview with Dr. Atul Gawande in the New Yorker by David Remnick – Atul Gawande on Coronavirus Vaccines and Prospects for Ending the Pandemic. It covers a lot of ground and Dr. Gawande is as insightful here as he is in his regular New Yorker pieces and many books. Continue reading

Well past time to support our healthcare workers – Part 2

I knew that Governor Gina Raimondo had announced a two week pause starting November 30th and that there were growing concerns about hospital capacity here in Rhode Island. But when I got this alert pushed to my phone Monday morning like everyone else in the state, it became very real again.

I knew there was discussion about opening a field hospital in Rhode Island. But when I saw that the lead story on one of the national morning news shows was an interview with the field hospital director on opening day December 1st, it became very real again.

I knew that our ED at the largest hospital in the state was at a breaking point as I have been following Dr. Megan Ranney closely on social media in recent weeks. But when I heard her describe what it is like in the ED on this week’s In the Bubble podcast with Andy Slavitt – “Following One Shift in the COVID-19 Unit”, it became very real again. Listening to her describe mentally getting ready for her shift, donning and doffing layers of PPE that is worn the entire shift, assessing and admitting very sick patients, calling families with updates, and heading out the door with her physically exhausted co-workers at the end of a long shift, I came to appreciate even more what our frontline healthcare workers are doing 24×7 in hospitals across the country.

I am not a denialist. Quite the opposite. I have taken this virus seriously since the start. I wear a mask whenever I’m out and can’t be socially distanced. I keep a journal of all our outings and contacts. I have the Crush Covid RI app that includes a location tracker diary for the past 20 days on my phone. I have watched many news stories, read many articles, and listened to many podcasts in the past 9 months. I feel very educated and informed. And at times, I feel very sad – so many stories have brought me to tears.

When I hear about new restrictions in my state, I typically tell my husband no change for us, we’re already living that way.

But it hit me different this week. Continue reading

With gratitude – yes, even in 2020

Difficult as 2020 has been, it is my hope that each of us can find something to be grateful for this Thanksgiving. If you have lost a loved one to COVID, I know that no words can take away your pain and grief. If you are a “long hauler”, I hope that you are finding support from others as you navigate your ongoing health issues. If you have lost your employment due to the economic downturn, I hope you are finding support from your network to find a new job.

Many times, during the past 9 months I have said to my family and friends – I can’t complain, I’m healthy and alive. I never really felt my age, but since March I have been reminded that I am an “elder”. I am overall healthy with no underlying conditions but I’m in that over 65 group. My husband is 4 years older than me and does have some medical conditions. We have been mask wearers since mid-March and do our best to minimize our risks.

I have much to be grateful for. Healthcare workers caring for COVID patients on the front lines and scientists working to develop a vaccine. All those who support them in ways we see and don’t see. And yes, that includes the IT and HTM teams in every health system who provide solutions and systems that the clinicians depend on.

I am also grateful for all the essential workers – at the grocery store, providing public transportation, delivering packages, and the police and firefighters who protect us.

My family are my big rocks. And that has never been truer than this year. I am eternally grateful for them. Continue reading

Well past time to support our healthcare workers

Any graph or heat map you look at, one thing is obvious – the coronavirus is out of control and spreading rapidly. New coronavirus cases have jumped by more than a third in the U.S. over the past seven days, according to data from Johns Hopkins University, the fastest pace since late March. Every day since Election Day, more than 100,000 people in the country have tested positive for the virus with a daily record of over 187,957 new cases last Friday per Worldometers.info. We went from 10 million new cases to 11 million in just one week. And we have lost over 250,000 lives.

We saw heartbreaking stories on the news from ICUs in the Northeast during March and April. Then stories from southern states. And now from hospitals in the Midwest. But when you look at the heat maps, the virus is everywhere now.

Listen to any healthcare worker and one more thing is obvious – they are exhausted and burning out. They tell story after story of how hard it is to work 12- and 18-hour shifts caring for COVID patients only to drive home past crowded bars.

We have seen exhausted physicians and nurses share their stories for months. I cannot tell their stories, but I can share them. And I can encourage you to do the same. But more importantly, I can encourage you to take the basic steps needed at this point – messages we have all heard for nearly 9 months now – wear a mask, socially distance, and wash your hands frequently.

This virus is not a hoax. It is not something you can ignore or deny. A story from a nurse in the Dakotas is the latest to go viral. She describes patients who yell at her and say she does not need to wear PPE because they don’t have COVID, right up until they are intubated.

Our healthcare workers truly are heroes, but they are at a breaking point. Our hospitals are at or nearing capacity. There are over 73,000 people hospitalized with COVID, another record since the pandemic started. Field hospitals are opening again in many states. Continue reading

Staying fit and informed

If you are working from home during this pandemic, getting enough exercise each day can be a challenge. I spoke to a CIO colleague recently who said he used to get 10,000 steps a day just at work given the size of his office complex.

I recently decided that I needed to up my exercise routine to ensure I get 10,000 steps a day. A long dog walk at the end of the workday plus the steps inside my house from my home office to the kitchen and back are just not enough. While I have never been an early morning exerciser, I am now two plus weeks into a new routine. Instead of rolling out of bed and starting on email and work right away, I now go for a brisk walk. I try to do a minimum of 30 minutes but depending on the time of my first scheduled call of the day, I do anywhere from 20-45 minutes. The end of day dog walk rounds it out to ensure I hit my 10,000 steps.

Besides the physical and mental health benefits of more exercise, I also have more time to stay informed via podcasts. A few weeks ago, I wrote about my latest podcast recommendations. With my new exercise routine, I am ready to recommend two more:

The Osterholm Update: COVID-19 – If you had not heard of Dr. Michael Osterholm pre-COVID, you probably recognize his name by now. Continue reading

Physical distancing: finding our way

We saw our grandkids again on Sunday. A small family get together for Father’s Day and our youngest grandchild’s 4th birthday. As we all find our way and do our best to minimize our risks of COVID-19, being able to hug my grandkids brings me great joy and is one of the things I have missed the most these past few months.

There is a reason many people want to refer to this new practice as physical distancing, not social distancing. We need each other. Social isolation is not healthy. Technology has helped but it is not the same. Just ask someone who said their final goodbye to a loved one on FaceTime or Zoom.

Living in Rhode Island, my husband and I have taken the shutdown very seriously. Governor Gina Raimondo got ahead of it early with the shutdown order and then a slow, phased reopening. From mid-March until a few weeks ago, we have mostly stayed home except for the weekly groceries, a few trips to the garden nursery and Home Depot, the occasional takeout order, and the daily dog walks.

We limited family visits to outside spaces at our homes at a distance and no hugs. We are gradually loosening up on the hugs. As we all learn more about how the virus is transmitted, spending time with close family who have also been strict during this period seems reasonable.

My 4-year-old grandson first told me back in April on a family Zoom session that he was going to have a birthday parade, no gifts, and a small cake only for his mom, dad, and sister. It was sad to hear him explain this at such a young age but I thought it was probably a reasonable plan. The idea of a parade was exciting to him. But two months later we decided it was ok to do the backyard immediate family only gathering, which was 12 adults and the 4 young cousins, aged 4 through 7. The grandkids gave us hugs and briefly sat on our laps. It was good to not feel like we were all radioactive.

The slow opening of our own circles is a challenge we all must deal with. I do not take this virus lightly. I read a lot and listen to many interviews and podcasts with experts. I try to be as informed as possible about the science. And I take cues from my sister who has a public health background and my daughter who is an NP and has cared for COVID-19 patients in Boston. Continue reading